[Throwback] Male power fantasies in Re:ZERO

Recording our recent podcast on Re:ZERO made me want to share one of the earliest explicitly feminist fandom posts I read, from a writer who has since become a personal friend and an honorary member of Team AniFem (and will one day write something for us, no doubt!). Re:ZERO and the White Knight Complex (Frogkun.com) The white knight complex is one of the reasons why I personally find harems so endlessly fascinating in spite of (or maybe because of?) their generally poor writing: they might say very little about how women are actually like, but they do say a whole lot about male anxieties. This is sort of related to what I was saying about all those otaku power fantasies in an earlier post, about how they offer a way for a disenfranchised male to depict himself as the top dog. If the male otaku in these stories can’t live up to the impossible ideals of heteronormative masculinity, his answer is not to reject those ideals altogether, but rather to create a world where he can cheat his way to the top. In this scenario, women are relegated to trophy status; by loving the protagonist, they affirm his manhood to the eyes of the world. People sometimes ask why we cover any texts targeting men, as if they should be exempt from feminist analysis. Posts like this (and the resulting conversation in comments) demonstrate the kinds of nuanced discussions we can have about male characters and masculinity by viewing shonen or seinen anime through a feminist lens. Read the full post then let us know what you think in comments below, or tell Frog-kun directly on Twitter @frog_kun!   Comments are open! Please read our comments policy before joining the conversation and contact us if you have any problems. Thanks to our generous patrons we are now able to pay all writers! Next we need to be able to pay members of the team for their work behind the scenes, especially their time spent editing the work of paid contributors. If you appreciate our work, believe in paying people fairly and can spare just $1 a month please become a patron today! 

[Throwback] Cosplaying while black

Earlier this week we invited you to showcase the contributions of black fans, and initial response was disheartening. It looks like our community just isn’t too aware of the work black fans and creators are doing in anime and manga fandom. To begin addressing that, let’s take a look at a 2013 post by Chaka, a.k.a. @princessology, creator of February’s #28DaysofBlackCosplay.

[Throwback] Revolutionary Girl Utena

One of our objectives on launch was to become something of a hub for content of interest to feminist fans of Japanese pop culture. I think we’re doing a decent job of this for recent content, not so much for the content that pre-dates us. So, starting today, we’re taking part in Throwback Thursday to post some of the great feminist content on anime, manga and other Japanese pop culture from the days before we existed and invite our readers to do the same. Most of the time this will be a link to a single older post with some commentary on why it stands out for us. Sometimes, like today, it will be a collection of links around a theme. This Throwback Thursday we’re celebrating the 20th anniversary of iconic, seminal classic Revolutionary Girl Utena. There are hundreds of articles out there about Utena, so we’re showcasing those written by our own team to get the ball rolling. From Vrai Kaiser: The Consulting Analyst – An Introduction to Revolutionary Girl Utena (Fashionable Tinfoil accessories) Vrai’s Consulting Analyst series breaks each episode of a show down to provide detailed critical commentary. Utena was a great choice for this format. Not only is it the second major project of auteur director Kunihiko Ikuhara (who also directed Sailor Moon) and share quite a bit of Evangelion’s creative staff, but the show is nothing less than a work of art both visually and narratively. It plays to classic shoujo sensibilities and undermines them, conjures fairytales and questions them, creates characters who are both heartrendingly young and thematically timeless, and packs an jaw-dropping wallop of a feminist allegory. From Dee: Utena Watch Party (Josei Next Door) Dee wrote posts directly responding to Vrai’s analysis, and invited everyone to join in. Part of the goal of this Watch Party is to increase Utena visibility; for all that it’s a hugely influential work and (I would argue) one of the best and most important anime out there, it hasn’t seen the level of popular exposure that many of the other ‘90s anime greats (like Evangelion, Cowboy Bebop, or Sailor Moon) have seen. And this is a shame, because it’s a uniquely excellent series, full of dynamic, layered characters, a great blend of humor and drama, gorgeous music, and artwork both beautiful and meaningful, packed with imagery and allegory. It’s also one of my favorite feminist narratives in any medium, anime or otherwise, as important if not more so than its predecessor, Sailor Moon. From Frog-kun: Froggy’s Top Anime: #9 Revolutionary Girl Utena (Frogkun.com) Honorary team member Frog-kun took a look at Utena from a more personal perspective. Utena is undeniably a rich show for analysis, but what made Frog-kun specifically connect with it? When I was a teenager, I always imagined myself as a white knight – like the prince Utena idealises. I never really understood the preoccupation young people have with darkness and edginess. White knighting was totally my chuunibyou. As I’ve gotten older, I have come to realise that this ideal is short-sighted, but it hasn’t dulled my sense of justice. In that sense, I have a great deal in common with Utena. Like her, I realise now that knights and princes aren’t the only arbiters of justice. Instead of aspiring to a particular form of masculinity, we can challenge the harmful stereotypes and make it easier for everyone to take control of their own lives. From Caitlin: Utena and the Four Horsemen of the Patriarchy (Heroine Problem) Finally, Caitlin took a fascinating and explicitly feminist approach to analysis in her four posts on Utena: Saionji and Violent Control Through Abuse Miki and the Virgin/Whore Complex Juri and Internalized Misogyny Touga and Gender Essentialism   What’s your favourite Utena commentary out there, be it a post, podcast or video? Link to it in comments below!   Comments are open! Please read our comments policy before joining the conversation and contact us if you have any problems. Thanks to our generous patrons we are now able to pay all writers! Next we need to be able to pay members of the team for their work behind the scenes, especially their time spent editing the work of paid contributors. If you appreciate our work, believe in paying people fairly and can spare just $1 a month please become a patron today!